Here’s one for Burning Our Money. The number of Defra staff earning more than £100,000 has trebled in the past five years.![]()
This cannot surely be linked to their performance as it struggles with waste and recycling, climate change, floods, coastal erosion, supporting our farmers – and ensuring they get their payments on time. We now learn that delays in payments have led to the taxpayer picking up the bill for spectacular fines totalling £63 million. The government has put by £292 million to cover the final cost of EU fines.
A press release just issued by the Conservative Press Office in Brussels describes how the cost of Margaret Beckett’s calamitous failure as Environment Secretary to get the 2005 Single Farm Payments out in time became clearer last night after it emerged British taxpayers had already paid £63 million in EU fines for failing to meet the statutory deadline.
The figure was published last night in a Commons written reply from Environment Minister Jonathan Shaw. The National Audit Office said last month that Defra has set aside a total of £292 million to cover possible fines, which are customarily announced by the Commission in the spring.
The Minister also revealed that the number of staff earning £100,000 or more at Defra had more than trebled in the past five years. In 2002, eight people were on such salaries, but that figure was 25 last year.
MEP Neil Parish, Conservative Agricultural spokesman for the EP, said:
“The fact our government has already paid out this much before the full extent of the fines has been announced suggests Defra is expecting an expensive rebuke from the European Commission.
“British farmers are still recovering from calamitous failures at Defra that led to so many farmers receiving their payments excessively late. Margaret Beckett introduced a complex system for making payments against all the advice being offered. While there has been widespread incompetence, the main reasons for the delay were poor Ministerial decisions.
“Unfortunately, while the EU is justified to impose these fines, current evidence suggests the Treasury will pay for them by cutting Defra’s budget.
“If Defra is to make cutbacks, perhaps it should begin by halting the huge number of officials on vast salaries. British farmers will be incensed to hear the department’s bureaucracy has bulged at a time when its frontline services are to be substantially cut.
“British farmers continue to suffer as a result of Labour.”
If these huge fines are to be offset against Defra at a time when it faces so many crucial challenges, how on earth is it going to improve on its delivery? Matters can only get worse, and this is very worrying as I believe our agricultural landscape particularly needs much more support, that food security and drought stress are very real problems we will be facing in the near future.
MEP Neil Parish clearly doesn’t know what he’s talking about.
British farmers were not affected by DEFRA’s failings, just English ones. Welsh & Scottish farmers continued to be paid under the existing system.
PS Ellee, your “recovering from calamitous” links to a BNP website! I thought you were a liberal Conservative!
The thrust of the article is the iniquity of senior officials being rewarded handsomely regardless of whether they succeed or fail in their duties; one of the more corrosive aspects of modern Britain is that they are rarely, if ever, brought to personal account and when they are it is usually with a big pay off.
Electro-Kevin, there are so many issues being raised here it’s difficult to know where to start!
When world food prices are rising significantly, why should any farmers be subsidised? I’m not in favour of wholesale subsidies that distort world food prices.
I fail to see why the UK should pay any fines to Europe. They should ignore them like the French and Germans do – you can assume I have never been a great fan of the EU except as a free trade area…
As to the the thrust of the argument, how do you know 100 DEFRA officials weren’t earning £98,000 five years ago!?!
I would certainly like to know how many DEFRA officials have been sacked for incompetence in recent times…
What happens if we don’t pay the fines? Does Margaret Beckett get thrown into jail in Brussels? Could be an idea…